A defendant that ignores a £10.8 million cladding claim does not hand the claimant an automatic win for the full sum. That is the message of Mulalley & Co Limited v Sto Limited and Sto SE & Co KGaA (2026) EWHC 2681 (TCC), handed down by Mr Justice Constable in the Technology and Construction Court on 20 October 2026 [1]. The contractor asked for a default judgment and a building liability order against the German parent of an insolvent cladding supplier, fixed at the whole amount it had been ordered to pay a building owner. The judge entered judgment, but refused to fix the figure. The amount must be assessed at a later hearing, on evidence.
Key takeaways
- The decision: on 20 October 2026 the TCC entered default judgment for Mulalley against Sto SE & Co KGaA, with the amount of the contribution to be assessed rather than fixed at £10,799,982.33 [1].
- The reason: a contribution claim is for whatever sum the court finds "just and equitable", so it is not a claim for a specified amount of money, however precisely the figure is pleaded [1].
- Building liability orders are not automatic: section 130 of the Building Safety Act 2022 lets the High Court make an order only where it considers it just and equitable to do so [1][2].
- Evidence still matters: in the sister case decided in June 2026, a chartered quantity surveyor's expert report reduced the claim before the judge awarded 87.5% of the proven loss, £1,772,312.17 [3].
What happened in Mulalley v Sto?
The cladding and the first trial
In 2005 Mulalley was engaged as design and build contractor for refurbishment works to a group of tower blocks owned by Martlet Homes Limited. The works included overcladding the concrete external walls with external wall insulation and a render finish. Sto Limited (Sto UK) provided the specification and the materials for the system, known as the StoTherm Classic System, which contained combustible expanded polystyrene insulation and an organic render [1].
After the Grenfell Tower fire, investigations revealed defects in the overcladding. Following an eight-day trial in March 2022, His Honour Judge Stephen Davies gave judgment for Martlet on 14 July 2022 in Martlet Homes Ltd v Mulalley & Co Ltd (2022) EWHC 1813 (TCC). That judgment describes the buildings as five tower blocks in Gosport [4]. The judge held that the system did not satisfy functional requirement B4(1) of the Building Regulations. Mulalley was ordered to pay £10,799,982.33, a figure that included damages, interest and Martlet's costs [1].
The claim against the supplier and its parent
Mulalley then claimed a contribution from Sto UK under the Civil Liability (Contribution) Act 1978. The argument was that Sto UK was itself liable to Martlet for the same damage under section 149 of the Building Safety Act 2022, which creates liability for past defaults relating to cladding products [1][5].
On 17 January 2025 Sto UK entered administration, and the claim against it became subject to a statutory moratorium. Mulalley obtained permission on 16 July 2025 to join Sto Germany, the parent company and sole shareholder of Sto UK. Against the parent it sought a building liability order under section 130 of the 2022 Act, so that Sto UK's liability would also become a liability of Sto Germany [1].
The default judgment application
Service on Sto Germany was completed on 20 January 2026. It did not acknowledge service by the 10 February 2026 deadline and did not file a defence. On 13 August 2026 Mulalley applied for judgment in default. Its primary case was for judgment in a specified amount of money: the whole judgment sum. Its fallback was judgment with the amount to be assessed. The hearing took place on 16 October 2026, with Mulalley unopposed [1].
What did the court decide about the building liability order?
Mr Justice Constable entered judgment, but with the amount of Sto UK's contribution under the 1978 Act to be assessed. He gave three linked reasons [1].
First, look at the substance of the claim. The judgment sum of £10,799,982.33 is fixed and identifiable. The contribution claimed in respect of it is not. Under section 2(1) of the 1978 Act, a contribution is such amount as the court finds just and equitable having regard to the extent of the other party's responsibility for the damage. Pleading a precise figure does not turn that evaluative question into a claim for a specified sum.
Second, section 130 has its own test. The judge noted that there is a distinct question whether it is just and equitable to make Sto UK's liability also a liability of Sto Germany. In his words, that is ordinarily:
"an evaluative judgment for the Court and does not follow merely from Sto Germany's default." [1]
Third, even if the pleading could be read as a claim for a specified amount, a hearing was still the right course. Given the two statutory exercises involved, the judge held that the overriding objective was best served by entering default judgment and directing an assessment.
The assessment hearing is to be listed on the first convenient date after 1 December 2026. Mulalley must provide disclosure and/or witness evidence within 28 days. Any application by Sto Germany to set aside the default judgment must be made within 28 days of service of the order [1].
What did the earlier Mulalley v Sto assessment show?
The October ruling follows a sister case between the same parties. In Mulalley & Co Limited v Sto Limited and Sto SE & Co KGaA (2026) EWHC 1552 (TCC), Mr Justice Pepperall assessed damages on 22 June 2026 after a hearing on 1 May 2026 [3].
That case concerned Parkside Court in Chelmsford, Essex, where Chelmer Housing Partnership Ltd had engaged Mulalley under a contract dated 30 December 2006 to build 27 new flats and refurbish a 54-flat tower block. The cladding again used the StoTherm Classic System. Mulalley settled with Chelmer on 22 December 2022, agreeing to remove and replace the cladding. Mr Justice Waksman entered default judgment against Sto Germany on 8 December 2025, for damages to be assessed [3].
The figures show how much an assessment can move a claim:
The judge accepted that the principal cause of the remedial works was that Sto marketed and supplied an inherently defective product, and set the just and equitable contribution at 87.5%, rather than the 90% Mulalley had sought [3].
Why does expert evidence still decide the amount under a building liability order?
The most important sentence for expert witnesses sits in the June judgment. Even though Sto Germany took no part, Mr Justice Pepperall said the assessment "is not made by default" and that Mulalley "must prove its loss or damage by evidence" [3]. Mr Justice Constable noted that principle in October [1].
At Parkside Court, Mulalley relied on an expert report from Tom Taylor, a chartered quantity surveyor, alongside factual witness statements. The judgment shows the expert doing four jobs [3]:
- Verifying cost. He reviewed a representative sample, including all the documents for the six subcontractors who accounted for nearly 97% of subcontractor cost.
- Making deductions against his own client. He reduced the total by a little over £302,000, including a main contractor's discount and reductions to preliminaries, subcontractor costs, and consultancy and legal fees.
- Separating what the defect caused from what it did not. The remedial works went beyond the defective render. He assessed that the Sto render accounted for 85.83% of the works to the tower's external walls and 69.03% of the overall development.
- Addressing reasonableness. He reported no evidence that costs were unreasonably incurred and no cheaper technical solution, and noted that a contractor fixing defects under a settlement had no interest in gold plating the works.
The judge accepted that evidence. An expert who trims the claim is more persuasive than one who simply adopts it, which reflects the overriding duty every expert owes to the court under CPR Part 35.
The same discipline applies to building surveyors, who must identify the defect, explain why it breaches the relevant standard, and show which remedial works flow from it. Similar habits appear in the guides on how surveyors document damage and risk in boundary and party wall disputes and on expert witness building surveyors in party wall damage claims.
Why does this matter for building defect disputes?
Section 149 is being used. It applies where a cladding product requirement was not met, a misleading statement was made about a cladding product, or a product was inherently defective, and that was a cause of a dwelling being unfit for habitation. The liability is owed to a person with a relevant interest in the building [5].
Insolvency does not always end the trail. A building liability order can make the liability of one company also a liability of an associated company. The relevant liabilities are those under the Defective Premises Act 1972, section 38 of the Building Act 1984, or as a result of a building safety risk, meaning fire spread or structural failure [2].
But the amount must be proved. A silent defendant removes the argument about liability on the pleaded case, not the need to prove the loss, its cause and its reasonableness.
What does the ruling mean for owners and leaseholders in Manchester and the North West?
The Mulalley cases concern buildings in Gosport and Chelmsford, and nothing in them is specific to this region. The principles apply across England and Wales. Recent coverage of the tribunal ruling against Urban Splash over fire safety defects in Manchester blocks shows that building safety liability is a live issue for local flat owners.
Sensible steps for freeholders, management companies, housing providers and leaseholder groups include:
- Record the defect before it is removed. Photographs, opening-up records and test results are hard to recreate once remedial works start.
- Keep remedial costs separable. Ask contractors to price and invoice defect-related work apart from improvements or unrelated repairs.
- Trace the corporate family early. If the original developer, contractor or supplier is insolvent, take legal advice on whether an associated company could be the target of a building liability order.
- Instruct independent experts in good time. They will need access to the records.
- Understand what a survey can show. Flat buyers can read about how property condition assessments will change building surveys and valuations and how to challenge a building survey valuation.
Frequently asked questions
What is a building liability order?
It is a High Court order under section 130 of the Building Safety Act 2022. It makes a relevant liability of one company, relating to a specified building, also a liability of one or more associated companies [2].
Did Mulalley win its case against Sto Germany?
Partly. The court entered default judgment in Mulalley's favour on 20 October 2026, but did not fix the amount. The contribution will be assessed at a hearing to be listed after 1 December 2026 [1].
Why was the amount not fixed if the defendant never responded?
Because the claim was for a contribution under the Civil Liability (Contribution) Act 1978. The amount of a contribution is whatever the court finds just and equitable, so the judge held it could not be treated as a claim for a specified amount of money [1].
Does a claimant need expert evidence if the defendant does not defend?
Usually, yes. The June 2026 judgment confirms that loss must still be proved by evidence. There, a chartered quantity surveyor's report was central to the figure awarded [3].
Conclusion
Mulalley v Sto confirms that there is no procedural shortcut to a building liability order for a fixed sum. A default judgment settles liability on the pleaded case, but the court will still weigh what is just and equitable and expect the loss to be proved.
Next steps for anyone with a defect claim: preserve the physical evidence, keep costs itemised, identify associated companies early, and take advice on independent expert evidence before remedial works begin.
This article is general information only and is not legal advice. Anyone affected by a building defects dispute should take advice from a solicitor on their own circumstances.
References
- Mulalley & Co Limited v Sto Limited and Sto SE & Co KGaA (2026) EWHC 2681 (TCC), Mr Justice Constable, 20 October 2026 (The National Archives, Find Case Law). caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk.
- Building Safety Act 2022, section 130: Building liability orders (legislation.gov.uk). legislation.gov.uk.
- Mulalley & Co Limited v Sto Limited and Sto SE & Co KGaA (2026) EWHC 1552 (TCC), Mr Justice Pepperall, 22 June 2026 (The National Archives, Find Case Law). caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk.
- Martlet Homes Ltd v Mulalley & Co Ltd (2022) EWHC 1813 (TCC), His Honour Judge Stephen Davies, 14 July 2022 (The National Archives, Find Case Law). caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk.
- Building Safety Act 2022, section 149: Liability for past defaults relating to cladding products (legislation.gov.uk). legislation.gov.uk.