Adjudication was designed for payment disputes between contractors. It is now being used to recover millions from the professionals who certify the work. In Coventry & Warwickshire Development Partnership LLP v Avison Young (UK) Limited (2026) EWHC 2319 (TCC), the Technology and Construction Court enforced an adjudicator's award of £8,729,179.33 against a firm acting as NEC project manager and supervisor [1]. The judgment is a lesson in professional negligence, adjudication and expert evidence all at once, because the adjudicator reached his figure after voicing "misgivings" about the experts on both sides.
Key Takeaways
- Summary judgment for the employer. Mr Justice Eyre held that the adjudicator's decision should be enforced.
- The claim was professional negligence. The developer said the project manager over-certified the contractor's payments. The contractor then became insolvent, so the overpayment could not be recovered from it.
- Both experts were doubted. The adjudicator rejected each side's earthworks baseline and drew on a third-party cost assessment.
- Every challenge failed. The court rejected arguments on jurisdiction, reasons, natural justice and severance.
- Speed cuts both ways. A complex negligence claim was decided in adjudication in under six months from referral.
The project and the dispute
The site is Gateway South in Coventry, a 215-acre former sewage treatment works being turned into an industrial and logistics park. The works were let under an NEC3 Engineering and Construction Contract, Option A. From January 2020 to January 2023, Avison Young acted as NEC project manager and supervisor.
The contractor later went into insolvency. The developer, known as CWDP, said that by then it had paid too much. Its case was that the project manager had:
- accepted reduced earthworks baseline quantities;
- accepted the contractor's own progress claims; and
- failed to identify defects.
The result, CWDP said, was that the "Price for Work Done to Date" in the payment certificates was too high. It put the overpayment at £25,374,883.84. Avison Young's answer was that its certification was reasonable, that any variance was negligible and that CWDP had suffered no loss.
The adjudication
The adjudicator found that the firm had "failed to carry out its duties under the Appointment to the required standard of skill and care". He held that Certificate No. 37, dated 3 February 2023, was over-valued by no less than £7,694,883.73. With interest, the loss came to £8,729,179.33.
He did not accept everything the developer said. Most of its defects claims were rejected, and credit was given on retention. He also rejected the firm's argument that recoveries under a performance bond reduced the loss.
How the expert evidence was handled
Each side relied on an expert. CWDP's expert criticised the firm's approach and said it had failed to consider the earthworks production data. The adjudicator accepted that point. But he considered the expert's proposed baseline quantity "unsafe to rely on", even though the figure had not been challenged.
The firm's expert said its approach appeared reasonable. The adjudicator did not adopt his baseline either.
The adjudicator said he had "misgivings about each" expert. He then looked at an independent cost assessment prepared by a firm of cost consultants in March 2024. He warned the parties that he might do so and invited submissions. The firm's stance was that the assessment should not be relied on.
An adjudicator who doubts both experts is not bound to pick one of them. If he warns the parties and asks for their views, he may take a third route.
The four challenges and why they failed
1. "He did not answer the dispute that was referred." The firm said the adjudicator had carried out a valuation exercise in place of deciding a negligence claim. The judge disagreed. Breach, causation and loss had all been addressed, even if the reasoning was interwoven with valuation. The adjudicator did not have to decide first whether the certified sums fell outside a reasonable range.
2. "The reasons were inadequate." The key paragraph on breach was a summing up of earlier analysis, not a bare assertion.
3. "Natural justice was breached." The adjudicator had given forewarning that he might use the third-party assessment and had invited submissions. The same went for retention and defects.
4. "Sever the bad parts." The judge refused. The retention finding was part of one chain of reasoning, and cutting it out would amount to the court recalculating the award.
The judgment grants summary judgment on enforcement. It does not state the final order, interest rate or costs.
Professional negligence, adjudication and expert evidence: lessons for surveyors
Certification is a professional act with real exposure. A project manager, contract administrator or quantity surveyor who certifies payment is expected to test the contractor's claim, not pass it on. That is most important when the contractor is in financial trouble.
Keep the working papers. Records of how quantities were measured and why a baseline was accepted are the best defence. Production data that exists but was never looked at is the worst.
Expect adjudication, not just litigation. Appointments for construction work will often fall within the statutory adjudication scheme. A negligence claim can be referred at any time and decided within weeks.
Experts in adjudication must be robust. There is usually no cross-examination. A report that does not deal with the other side's data, or that offers a figure without showing how it was built, may simply be set aside.
Engage with new material. If an adjudicator says he is minded to use a document, the safest course is to address it on the merits as well as objecting to it.
Know the expert witness standard. The RICS professional standard Surveyors acting as expert witnesses (5th edition) takes effect on 30 November 2026 and applies to surveyors giving expert evidence to any tribunal, which includes adjudicators [2].
Why this matters in Manchester
Greater Manchester has one of the busiest development pipelines outside London, from logistics parks along the M60 and M62 to city-centre towers. Much of that work is run under NEC contracts by surveying firms acting as project manager, supervisor or employer's agent. Contractor insolvency remains a live risk across the sector. When a contractor fails mid-project, the employer's next question is whether it has been over-certified, and who signed the certificates.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can a professional negligence claim be decided by adjudication?
Yes, where the professional's appointment is a construction contract under the Housing Grants, Construction and Regeneration Act 1996. This case is an example.
Is an adjudicator's decision final?
No. It is binding until the dispute is finally decided in court or arbitration or by agreement. But it must be paid in the meantime.
On what grounds will the court refuse to enforce?
Broadly, where the adjudicator had no jurisdiction or there was a material breach of natural justice. Errors of fact or law within jurisdiction are not enough.
Does the adjudicator have to accept one of the experts?
No. He must decide the dispute fairly on the material before him.
Conclusion
CWDP v Avison Young shows that certifying professionals can face eight-figure claims in a fast, rough-and-ready forum, and that the court will enforce the result unless something has gone seriously wrong with the process.
Manchester surveyors acting as project manager or contract administrator should review how interim valuations are checked and recorded. Employers who suspect over-certification should take early advice on adjudication. Both sides should instruct independent experts whose reports can stand on paper without oral evidence to prop them up.
This article is general information on a recent judgment and is not legal advice.
References
- Coventry & Warwickshire Development Partnership LLP v Avison Young (UK) Limited (2026) EWHC 2319 (TCC). caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk.
- RICS, Surveyors acting as expert witnesses. rics.org.