In 13 days, every RICS member who gives expert evidence will be working under new rules. The RICS professional standard Surveyors acting as expert witnesses, 5th edition, takes effect on 30 November 2026 [1]. It was published in July 2026 and replaces the previous edition. For surveyors and solicitors in Manchester and the North West, the practical question is short: are your instructions, reports and fee terms ready?
Key Takeaways
- Effective date: 30 November 2026 [1].
- Duty: the expert's primary duty is to the tribunal, not the client [1].
- AI: any use of artificial intelligence in the work must be identified in the report [1].
- Money: financial dependence on one instructing party must be disclosed, and outcome-based fees are barred except in exceptional circumstances [1].
- Roles: acting as both advocate and expert is prohibited unless strict conditions are met [1].
What the RICS Surveyors Acting as Expert Witnesses 5th Edition Covers
The standard applies to expert evidence before a wide range of bodies. "Tribunal" is read broadly and includes courts, statutory tribunals, arbitration, adjudication (including construction adjudication), planning inquiries, expert determination and early neutral evaluation [1]. It does not apply when a member is only a witness of fact [1].
It is read alongside separate RICS practice guidance for surveyors acting as expert witnesses [2].
The core statement is this:
"The primary duty of an expert witness is not to a client or person instructing them but to the tribunal itself" [1].
Opinions must be truthful, impartial and independent. Misleading by leaving something out is treated as seriously as saying something wrong [1].
The Main Requirements at a Glance
A Readiness Checklist Before 30 November 2026
For surveyor experts
- Update the terms of engagement. They should confirm that the standard and the tribunal's rules apply, that the overriding duty is to the tribunal, and that the firm's complaints procedure will not apply to the expert work [1].
- Review fee arrangements. Remove anything that links payment to the result. The narrow exception needs a pre-existing arrangement, tribunal rules that allow it, the client's informed consent and disclosure to the tribunal [1].
- Check for financial dependence. If one solicitor, insurer or landlord provides a significant share of income, that must be disclosed in the report [1].
- Set an AI policy. Decide which tools may be used, and record their use so the report can identify it [1].
- Refresh the report template. Include the declarations, statement of truth, a section on limitations, and a section on alternative views [1].
- Record inspections. If an inspection was incomplete, say so and explain what follows from that [1].
For instructing solicitors
- Ask about conflicts and income dependence at the outset. An undisclosed conflict found later can damage the whole case.
- Do not propose success-based fees for expert work.
- Give clear written instructions, and expect the expert to keep a record of them.
- Ask how AI was used, if at all.
- Keep advocacy and expert roles separate.
How This Fits With CPR Part 35 and the AI Debate
The standard sits alongside the court's own rules. Under CPR Part 35 and Practice Direction 35, an expert's overriding duty is to the court, and the report must carry a statement of truth. Where the court's rules and the RICS standard both apply, an expert should meet both.
Artificial intelligence is the fastest-moving part. On 29 October 2026 the Civil Justice Council published its final report on the use of AI in preparing court documents. It recommended that expert witnesses declare where AI generated or influenced substantive content and disclose the tools used [3]. That is a recommendation, not yet a rule, but it points the same way as the RICS standard.
RICS has also signalled more to come. Its Standards and Regulation Board said in September 2026 that consultations on AI in alternative dispute resolution and on a new edition of its conflicts of interest standard would launch in autumn 2026 [4].
Why It Matters in Manchester and the North West
Surveyors in the region give evidence in building defects claims, dilapidations disputes, boundary cases, valuation disputes and housing disrepair claims. In each, the weight a judge gives the evidence depends on independence and transparency. A report that meets the 5th edition is harder to attack. One that does not may attract criticism from the tribunal, with consequences for the client and the expert.
Frequently Asked Questions
When does the 5th edition take effect?
On 30 November 2026 [1].
Does it apply to adjudication and arbitration?
Yes. The definition of tribunal is wide and includes both [1].
Can an expert use AI?
The standard does not ban it. It requires the use to be confirmed in writing and identified in the report [1].
Can an expert be paid on a success basis?
Not for new expert work. Outcome-dependent fees are barred except in exceptional circumstances that meet every condition [1].
Conclusion
The RICS Surveyors acting as expert witnesses 5th edition is not a rewrite of the expert's role. It is a tighter, clearer statement of it, with new attention to AI, money and independence. Thirteen days is enough time to update terms of engagement, fee arrangements and report templates, but not much more.
Surveyors should work through the checklist now. Solicitors should ask their experts to confirm, in writing, that they are ready.
This article is general information only and is not legal advice. Take advice on your own circumstances.
References
- RICS, Surveyors acting as expert witnesses, 5th edition (July 2026, effective 30 November 2026). rics.org.
- RICS, "Surveyors acting as Expert Witnesses" standards page. rics.org.
- Mayer Brown, "Legal Developments in Construction Law: November 2026" (16 November 2026). mayerbrown.com.
- RICS, "Upholding standards and professionalism: SRB's Q3 update" (10 September 2026). rics.org.