{"content":[]}
A 260-page judgment, two hearing blocks running from April to July, and orders totalling £46,500,650: the First-tier Tribunal's decision in the Urban Splash case, issued on 5 November 2026, is the clearest demonstration yet of how remediation contribution order expert evidence is tested under the Building Safety Act 2022 [1]. All seven buildings sit in Manchester, and the tribunal sat at Manchester Civil Justice Centre. For Greater Manchester surveyors, building owners and leaseholders, the case shows what technical evidence must look like when tens of millions of pounds turn on it.
Key Takeaways
- The First-tier Tribunal (Property Chamber) made remediation contribution orders of £46,500,650 under section 124 of the Building Safety Act 2022 against five Urban Splash entities, jointly and severally [1].
- Urban Splash challenged whether the remediation methods were proportionate and whether cheaper alternatives existed. The tribunal favoured the Secretary of State on the key technical issues but did not award the full amount sought [1].
- A 10% reduction on the publicly funded element reflected government's contribution to the wider building-safety crisis, expressly not a finding that government caused 10% of the defects [1][2].
- The RICS professional standard "Surveyors acting as expert witnesses", 5th edition, takes effect on 30 November 2026 and raises the bar for exactly this kind of evidence [3].
What the Tribunal Decided
The applicant was the Secretary of State for Housing, Communities and Local Government. The decision carries the neutral citation [2026] UKFTT 01426 (PC) and was heard by a panel of Judge J Holbrook, Regional Judge N Walsh and Mr A Gee RIBA. Hearings ran from 27 April to 15 May 2026 and again from 8 June to 1 July 2026 [1].
Section 124 of the Building Safety Act 2022 allows the tribunal, on the application of an interested person, to order a specified body corporate or partnership to contribute to the cost of remedying relevant defects where it considers that "just and equitable" [1]. The orders were made jointly and severally against:
- Urban Splash Limited
- Urban Splash Developments Limited
- Urban Splash Group Holdings Limited
- Urban Splash Work Limited
- Stubbs Mill LLP
Of the total, £741,594 is payable to Moho Management Company Ltd and the balance to the Secretary of State. No orders were made against four other respondents, and applications against two more were withdrawn after settlement [1].
Judge Holbrook said there was a "powerful case" for the developer "rather than the taxpayer, to bear the remediation costs". He accepted that Urban Splash had given "useful and responsible assistance" to post-Grenfell investigations, but drew "an important distinction between assisting those investigations and accepting financial responsibility" [2].
Urban Splash did not own the buildings when the works were done and received no Building Safety Fund money itself. The company said it is reviewing the decision and taking legal advice, called the liability "significant for a business of our size", and described the Act's reach, in catching associated entities, as having "far-reaching consequences" [1][2].
The Seven Manchester Buildings and the Defects
The buildings were developed between roughly 2000 and 2008 [1]:
- Burton Place
- The Chips Building
- The Moho Building
- The Box Works
- Emmeline House, Christabel House and Sylvia House, the three Dalton Street blocks known as the "Three Towers"
The defects fell into familiar post-Grenfell categories: combustible external materials, defective or missing cavity barriers, and deficiencies in fire stopping and compartmentation [1][2]. Their extent was disputed, but the tribunal found fire-safety-related defects in each building [2]. The firm's earlier piece on the Urban Splash ruling and what it means for flat owners and buyers covers the headline findings; this article focuses on the evidence.
Remediation Contribution Order Expert Evidence: How the Technical Case Was Tested
Section 124 proceedings are not negligence claims. The questions are whether a relevant defect exists, what it reasonably costs to remedy, and whether it is just and equitable for the respondent to pay. Each rests on technical evidence.
Proving the defect exists and how far it extends
The extent of the defects was contested [2]. External wall systems built in the early 2000s were rarely documented to modern standards, so experts must reconstruct what was installed from intrusive inspections, archive drawings and product data, and state their assumptions where the evidence is thin.
Testing reasonableness and proportionality of the remedy
Urban Splash's central technical challenge was that the remediation methods chosen were disproportionate and that cheaper alternatives existed. The tribunal favoured the Secretary of State on the key technical issues but still did not award the full amount sought [1]. A tribunal engaged with the engineering detail rather than rubber-stamping a funding decision, and a respondent's expert can still reduce the figure where criticism is specific and evidenced.
The approach echoes Mulalley & Co Ltd v Sto Ltd and Sto SE & Co. KGaA [2026] EWHC 1552 (TCC), decided on 22 June 2026, where Pepperall J held the remediation costs reasonable and noted that courts are generally reluctant to second-guess a claimant's remedial spending with hindsight. The claimant recovered £1,772,312.17, or 87.5% of its recoverable losses, under a building liability order against the German parent of an insolvent cladding supplier [4]. Hindsight criticism needs more than a cheaper price list. It needs a credible, buildable alternative that would have met the regulatory requirement at the time.
The role of a technical panel member
The panel included Mr A Gee RIBA [1]. A professionally qualified member changes how expert evidence is received: generalisations are exposed quickly and experts who stray outside their discipline are noticed. Reports should assume at least one reader understands cavity barriers and compartmentation as well as the author.
The duty to the tribunal
Experts in tribunal proceedings owe the same overriding duty as experts under CPR Part 35: to help the tribunal on matters within their expertise, independently of the party paying the fee. A report that reads as advocacy does not help the instructing party in a case of this size.
What Changes on 30 November 2026 for Surveyor Experts
The RICS professional standard "Surveyors acting as expert witnesses", 5th edition, published in July 2026, takes effect on 30 November 2026 and applies to RICS members worldwide [3]. Its requirements map directly onto the kind of evidence a section 124 case demands:
- Assumptions and alternatives. Reports must list all assumptions, give alternative conclusions where legal assumptions are disputed, address competing schools of thought and explain why alternatives were rejected [3]. In a proportionality dispute, that means setting out the cheaper options and saying why they were or were not adequate.
- Third-party and AI contributions. Experts must identify work done by others or with AI tools and explain their methods [3]. Fire modelling and cost analysis often involve both.
- Conflicts and regular instructions. Where one party supplies a large share of an expert's income, that must be disclosed [3].
- Accountability. Poor practice can lead to tribunal criticism, adverse costs, negligence claims or RICS disciplinary action [3].
The firm's guide to how expert witness building surveyors win party wall damage claims applies the same disciplines at a domestic scale: inspect thoroughly, record everything, separate fact from opinion.
What It Means for Manchester Leaseholders and Building Owners
Manchester's city-centre stock includes many blocks from the same era as the Urban Splash buildings. The decision points to several practical steps.
Commission or update an external wall appraisal. A current, intrusive assessment of external materials, cavity barriers and compartmentation is the foundation of any future claim or defence. The firm's article on RICS building survey standards and what surveyors must check explains how a methodical inspection is structured.
Preserve the records. Specifications, contractor correspondence, building control records, fire risk assessments and remediation tenders all become evidence of what was built, by whom, and what it cost to fix.
Document remediation decisions as they are made. Owners who record why a method was chosen, what alternatives were considered and why they were rejected will be far better placed if that decision is later questioned, as it was here [1].
Map the corporate structure. Orders were made against five associated entities, jointly and severally [1]. Leaseholders and managing agents should identify the full corporate family behind their building's development.
Buyers should ask the right questions. Anyone buying a flat in a pre-2010 block should ask whether an application under the Act has been made, what the remediation status is, and who funded the works. A Level 3 building survey does not inspect the full external wall system, but a surveyor who knows the local stock will flag the risk and point to the right specialist report.
The Wider Enforcement Trend
Urban Splash is part of a pattern. In Crest Nicholson Regeneration Ltd v Ardmore Construction Ltd [2026] EWHC 789 (TCC), an adjudicator awarded £14,928,320.40 for fire-safety defects in five Portsmouth buildings; Ardmore entered administration the day before the award, and Crest pursued building liability orders against associated companies [5]. Every one of these routes depends on technical evidence that survives cross-examination. The Act creates the liability; surveyors and fire engineers decide whether it can be proved.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a remediation contribution order?
An order under section 124 of the Building Safety Act 2022 requiring a specified body corporate or partnership to contribute to the cost of remedying relevant defects, where the First-tier Tribunal considers it just and equitable [1].
Why was the award reduced by 10%?
The tribunal reduced the publicly funded element by 10% to reflect government's own contribution to the wider building-safety crisis, expressly not a finding that government caused 10% of the defects. Further adjustments included an earlier settlement [1][2].
Conclusion
The Urban Splash orders show public money spent on making Manchester buildings safe being recovered from the companies that developed them, on the strength of detailed technical evidence rather than who owned the buildings at the time [1][2]. Building owners and leaseholders should get the evidence in order now, through a current external wall appraisal, a complete records archive and a documented rationale for every remediation decision. Surveyors should write every report as if a RIBA-qualified panel member will read it and as if the RICS 5th edition already applies, because from 30 November 2026 it will [3].
Manchester Surveyors provides building surveys, defect investigations and expert witness reports for building owners, managing agents, leaseholders and their solicitors across Greater Manchester.
References
- Urban Splash Ruling. planninggeek.co.uk.
- Developer Told to Pay 45m to Government for Post Grenfell Repairs. itv.com.
- Rics 2026 Expert Witness Guidance Key Changes for Surveyors. rimkus.com.
- Building Safety Act 2022 November 2026 Update. ts-p.co.uk.
- Crest Nicholson V Ardmore 2026 Ewhc 789 Tcc a Landmark Decision on Building Liability Orders. pumpcourtchambers.com.