A £100,000 damages award turned on a single estate agent's letter from September 2019. No surveyor valued the property. No mortgage statements were obtained. The judge worked out the equity himself. For anyone handling a valuation evidence property dispute Manchester courts are hearing right now, MPP (Services) Ltd v Ratio Law Solicitors LLP, handed down on 6 November 2026, is a reminder that the value of a home is often the number that decides the case, and that parties too often leave it to chance [1].
Key Takeaways
- A Manchester investment company recovered £100,000 plus interest from its former solicitors after a drafting error left a legal charge over a house void for uncertainty.
- The only evidence of the house's value was an estate agent's report dated 3 September 2019 putting it at £300,000. The judge accepted that figure because it was not challenged in cross-examination.
- The judge estimated the available equity at around £180,000 and noted the defendant could have obtained mortgage statements but did not.
- The award reflects the lost chance of a settlement, not the full sum secured.
- Parties relying on a property as security, or litigating about one, should obtain a RICS Red Book valuation and, where proceedings are contemplated, expert valuer evidence under CPR Part 35.
The background to this valuation evidence property dispute in Manchester
MPP (Services) Ltd is an investment company run by two directors, Steven Reel and Stephen Carroll. It had been involved in a joint venture to open a children's care home at properties in Cheadle. The venture failed, mainly because planning permission was unlikely, and the parties fell out in October 2019 [1].
Lesley Hearne, a care home manager and a friend of Mr Reel, was said to owe the company about £180,000 arising from the failed venture. In April 2019 she signed a legal charge over her house, Laurel Bank, intended to secure that sum [1].
Ratio Law Solicitors LLP acted on the charge. Its fee-earner, Ms Alberici, reviewed the draft, deleted the sum from the charge and did not replace it. When the company later tried to enforce, Ms Hearne argued that the charge was void for uncertainty. The judge described that defence as effectively unanswerable. The company settled with her at mediation and cancelled the charge [1].
The firm admitted breach of duty. The trial before HH Judge Stephen Davies, sitting as a High Court judge in the Circuit Commercial Court in Manchester from 29 September to 1 October 2026, was about causation, scope of duty, remoteness, mitigation and the value of the chance the company had lost. George Rowell appeared for the claimant and Zachary Bredemear for the defendant [1].
How the property's value was proved, and how it was not
The company's recovery depended on what it could have obtained from Ms Hearne had the charge been valid. That in turn depended on the value of Laurel Bank and the equity in it.
The judge accepted the £300,000 figure because Ms Hearne did not dispute it when cross-examined. The mortgage balance was in dispute, and the judge found the available equity was likely around £180,000, observing that the defendant could have obtained mortgage statements but had not [1].
A planning consultant, James Stannard, had been involved in the planning applications but was not called; his emails were treated as documentary evidence [1].
In a claim that turned on how much a house was worth and how much was owed on it, nobody put a surveyor or a mortgage statement before the court.
The witnesses and the outcome
The judge found Ms Hearne an unreliable witness and rejected her claim that she had been misled into signing. He found Mr Reel reasonably honest and reliable, although his recollection of a telephone call with Ms Alberici was not fully accurate; the judge accepted, by a narrow margin, that the call took place. Ms Alberici was found to be an unimpressive witness, and the firm's response letter was criticised as misleading [1].
On damages, the judge assessed the lost chance at £100,000, the figure a likely settlement with Ms Hearne would have reached. He linked that sum to £70,000 of fees paid to her plus a £20,000 loan and interest. The award was £100,000 plus interest, provisionally at 3% over base rate from 10 October 2021, with the parties invited to make submissions on the interest calculation. No separate award was made for the costs of pursuing Ms Hearne [1].
Why formal valuation evidence matters in a property dispute Manchester courts will hear
This case was decided on the evidence the parties chose to bring. The outcome might have been different, in either direction, with better evidence.
An appraisal is not a valuation
An estate agent's marketing appraisal is an opinion of likely asking price, prepared to win an instruction. A RICS Red Book valuation is a reasoned opinion of market value, prepared by a regulated valuer who inspects the property, considers comparable evidence and states assumptions. Courts will take what they are given, but a party who relies on an appraisal invites the other side to undermine it.
Equity is a calculation, not a guess
The security value of a home is the market value less what is owed on prior charges. Mortgage statements are easy to obtain. Leaving the judge to estimate equity hands the decision to chance.
Condition affects both figures
A building surveyor's report on condition can change a valuation materially, especially for older housing stock across Greater Manchester. Defects, damp or structural movement would have reduced the realisable value and therefore the lost chance.
Expert evidence: when a Part 35 valuer should be instructed
Where the value of property is a live issue in litigation, the normal course is to seek permission for expert valuation evidence under CPR Part 35, ideally from a single joint expert in a lower-value claim. Practice Direction 35 requires the expert to set out their instructions, the evidence relied on, the range of reasonable opinion and a statement of truth. The RICS professional standard Surveyors acting as expert witnesses, 5th edition, effective from 30 November 2026, requires independence and a clear duty to the court.
In a lost-chance claim like this one, a Part 35 valuer would have addressed the value of Laurel Bank at the date the charge would have been enforced, the likely realisation costs, and the equity after prior charges. That evidence would have given the court a firmer footing than an unchallenged agent's letter.
What this means for lenders, investors and homeowners in Manchester
- If you are taking security over a home, obtain a Red Book valuation and up-to-date mortgage statements before you lend.
- If you are the borrower, remember that your home's value will be scrutinised if the arrangement goes wrong.
- Keep every document about the debt and the property together; the court will use whatever exists.
What this means for surveyors and solicitors
- Solicitors litigating about secured debts should plead and prove value and equity with proper evidence, not leave the gap to cross-examination.
- Valuers instructed in disputes should be clear whether they are giving a Red Book valuation, a retrospective valuation, or Part 35 expert evidence, and comply with the relevant standard.
- Where the other side relies on an agent's appraisal, challenge it. Unchallenged figures become findings.
Conclusion
MPP (Services) Ltd v Ratio Law is a solicitors' negligence case, but its lesson is about valuation evidence. A valuation evidence property dispute Manchester litigants bring to court will be decided on the figures in the bundle. Here those figures came from an estate agent's letter and a judge's estimate of equity. A Red Book valuation, mortgage statements and, where proportionate, a Part 35 expert valuer would have given the court, and the parties, something more solid to work with. The judgment is published on the National Archives Find Case Law service [1].
References
- MPP (Services) Ltd v Ratio Law Solicitors LLP (2026) EWHC 2852 (Comm), Circuit Commercial Court (Manchester), HH Judge Stephen Davies, 6 November 2026. caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk.