A landlord claimed between about £1.2 million and £1.6 million for a worn-out office building. The court agreed the tenant had broken its repairing covenant, yet the tenants were reported to have been ordered to pay roughly 60% less than claimed. That is the headline from Craigard (Dartford) Ltd & Anor v Westbury Homes (Holdings) Ltd & Anor (2026) EWHC 2453 (TCC), a Technology and Construction Court judgment of 29 September 2026 [1]. For anyone preparing or defending a dilapidations claim in Greater Manchester, the lesson is clear: proving disrepair is only the first step. The harder task is proving what it reasonably costs to put right, and whether the landlord would have spent that money anyway.
Key Takeaways
- Where repair and replacement would both satisfy a repairing covenant, damages are measured by the cheaper, less onerous option [1].
- A landlord's pre-existing refurbishment plan does not cancel the primary claim for repair costs, but it can sink a loss of rent claim [2].
- Expert evidence must separate the minimum works needed to remedy a breach from wider upgrade works [2].
- Dilapidations surveyors acting as expert witnesses owe their duty to the court under CPR Part 35, and from 30 November 2026 must set out assumptions and alternative conclusions in their reports [3][4].
The Facts and Holdings in Craigard v Westbury Homes
The lease of a multi-let office building in Dartford expired in 2023, and the landlord brought a terminal dilapidations claim covering remedial works, loss of rent and professional fees [1]. The central battleground was the heating, ventilation and air-conditioning (HVAC) system: the landlord wanted full replacement, while the tenant argued that repair would meet the covenant [1].
Four findings matter for every future dilapidations claim:
- Disrepair was proven. The HVAC system was in disrepair at lease expiry and had not been properly maintained [1].
- Replacement was not proven. The landlord had not shown that wholesale replacement was necessary to comply with the repairing covenant [1].
- The less onerous option sets the measure. Applying the established principle from the Ultraworth and Sunlife cases, where either repair or replacement could reasonably achieve compliance, damages are assessed by the cheaper route, which here was repair [1].
- Planned refurbishment cut the loss of rent claim. The landlord had decided, well before expiry, to replace the system as part of a wider refurbishment to improve the building's environmental credentials and reposition it. That did not extinguish the primary claim for the reasonable cost of repair, but the loss of rent claim failed because those losses would have arisen during the planned works regardless of the tenant's breaches [2].
Section 18(1) of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1927, the diminution-in-value cap, was also in play [2].
Why Repair Beat Replacement in This Dilapidations Claim
A repairing covenant does not oblige a tenant to hand back a better building than the one it took. Where there are two reasonable ways to meet the covenant, the tenant is only liable for the cheaper one [1]. The landlord's difficulty was evidential. Showing that chillers, air handling units and controls are tired and poorly maintained is one thing. Proving that no reasonable programme of repair could bring them back to covenant standard is another. Without that proof, the court defaulted to repair as the measure of loss [1]. A dilapidations claim built on a replacement figure must therefore rest on plant condition evidence that rules out repair.
Why the Retrofit Plans Sank the Loss of Rent Claim
The landlord's intention to replace the HVAC system was fixed long before expiry and driven by a desire to upgrade and reposition the building [2]. That intention did not wipe out the repair claim [2]. But loss of rent is a consequential loss, and the landlord had to show that the tenant's breaches caused the void period. Because the building would have been out of use during the planned refurbishment anyway, that head of claim failed [2].
Ian Morgan of Pinsent Masons advised landlords to obtain expert evidence that separates the minimum works needed to remedy a breach from wider refurbishment [2]. That separation is now central to any well-prepared schedule.
What This Means for a Manchester Dilapidations Claim
Greater Manchester has a large stock of 1980s to 2000s offices in Spinningfields, Salford Quays and around NOMA, older industrial units in Trafford Park and converted retail space in the Northern Quarter. Much of it has original plant nearing the end of its service life, and landlords are under pressure to improve EPC ratings through repositioning schemes.
Craigard matters here for three reasons:
- Replacement will be challenged. A tenant's surveyor will ask for evidence that repair was not a reasonable option. If the answer is "the landlord is upgrading anyway", the claim is exposed.
- Refurbishment plans are discoverable. Board papers and EPC improvement plans will be examined to see what the landlord intended before expiry, and used to argue supersession under section 18(1) and to attack loss of rent [2].
- Timing of decisions is critical. The earlier a landlord commits to a scheme, the harder it becomes to argue that a void period was caused by the tenant.
The Expert Evidence Angle: What Dilapidations Surveyors Must Prove
The RICS "Dilapidations in England and Wales" professional statement (7th edition) and the Dilapidations Pre-Action Protocol already require a schedule of dilapidations, a Quantified Demand and a surveyor's endorsement confirming that the works and costs are reasonable [4]. Craigard raises the bar for what sits behind that endorsement.
Building condition evidence
A schedule should record the actual condition of each element at expiry, with dated photographs and inspection notes. Generic phrases such as "plant beyond economic life" will not carry a replacement claim [1].
Plant condition reports and M&E specialist input
HVAC disputes turn on engineering facts: age, maintenance history, spares availability and the feasibility of repair. A building surveyor should bring in a mechanical and electrical specialist early, and that specialist should address repair as a serious option before concluding that replacement is needed [2].
Separating repair from improvement
Every item should be labelled as either breach remedy or improvement. Where the landlord intends an upgrade, the report should identify and price separately the minimum works that would have satisfied the covenant [2]. Section 18(1) supersession arguments are won or lost here.
The surveyor's endorsement and CPR Part 35 duties
The endorsement is a personal professional statement, and signing off an unsupported figure invites criticism in court. Once proceedings are in prospect, a dilapidations surveyor acting as an expert witness owes an overriding duty to the court that trumps any obligation to the instructing party, and must set out the range of opinion where it exists [3]. The RICS "Surveyors acting as expert witnesses" standard (5th edition), effective 30 November 2026, adds that reports must set out assumptions and alternative conclusions [4]. An expert who has only modelled replacement, and never priced repair, will struggle to comply.
Manchester Surveyors prepares and responds to schedules of dilapidations across Greater Manchester and provides expert witness evidence that meets CPR Part 35 and RICS requirements, with coordinated M&E input on ageing plant.
Practical Steps for Landlords and Tenants at Lease End
For landlords:
- Commission a plant condition survey 12 to 18 months before expiry, with repair costed alongside replacement.
- Record when and why refurbishment decisions were made, and expect disclosure.
- Separate breach remedy from improvement in the schedule from the outset.
- Test loss of rent claims against the refurbishment programme before issuing the Quantified Demand.
For tenants:
- Gather maintenance and servicing records for the whole term.
- Consider carrying out repair works before expiry where the lease allows.
- Ask for disclosure of the landlord's plans and any EPC strategy.
- Instruct an independent surveyor to test the schedule against the least onerous method principle and section 18(1).
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Craigard mean a landlord can never recover replacement costs?
No. Replacement remains recoverable where the evidence shows that repair could not reasonably achieve compliance. The judgment turned on a failure of proof, not a change in the law [1].
If the landlord planned a refurbishment anyway, does the tenant pay nothing?
Not necessarily. In Craigard the primary claim for the reasonable cost of repair survived. Only the loss of rent claim failed, because the void would have occurred in any event [2].
How does section 18(1) of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1927 fit in?
Section 18(1) caps damages at the reduction in the value of the landlord's interest caused by the disrepair, so a landlord's refurbishment plans feed directly into that analysis [2].
What changes under the new RICS expert witness standard?
From 30 November 2026, expert reports must set out the assumptions relied on and any alternative conclusions. For dilapidations, repair and replacement options should both be addressed where realistic [4].
Conclusion
Craigard v Westbury Homes confirms that a dilapidations claim rises or falls on evidence. Disrepair was proven, yet recovery was reportedly cut by roughly 60% because the landlord could not show that replacement was necessary and its own refurbishment plans explained the loss of rent [1][2]. For Manchester landlords with ageing plant and EPC-driven programmes, the lesson is to separate repair from improvement early. For tenants, it is to challenge remedies rather than deny breaches.
Next steps: review upcoming lease expiries, commission plant condition evidence in good time, and ensure any surveyor instructed as an expert understands their CPR Part 35 and RICS duties. Manchester Surveyors can assist with schedules, Quantified Demands, responses and expert witness reports.
References
- Repair Replacement and Retrofit What Craigard V Westbury Homes Means for Dilapidations Claims. mills-reeve.com.
- High Court Clarifies Limits of Dilapidations Claims Where Landlords Plan Sustainability Upgrades. pinsentmasons.com.
- Part35. justice.gov.uk.
- Surveyors Acting as Expert Witnesses. rics.org.