Six years of using a carport, a new lock on the door and a false wall at the back were not enough. In Holmes v O'Hara (2026) UKFTT 1514 (PC), decided on 15 October 2026, the First-tier Tribunal (Property Chamber) cancelled a Batley couple's application to register a carport behind their end-of-terrace house, because the land was unregistered and they could not prove the full period needed for adverse possession unregistered land twelve years [1]. The judge noted they may succeed if they stay in possession for another six years.
The case is short, practical and very familiar to anyone who owns a terraced house in Manchester, Salford or Stockport, where back yards, ginnels, garages and access roads often sit outside every title plan. This article explains what went wrong, what evidence the Tribunal accepted and rejected, and what northern homeowners and their surveyors should take from it. It is general information, not legal advice.
Key Takeaways
- Unregistered land requires twelve years' adverse possession under the Limitation Act 1980; registered land requires ten years under a different regime.
- The applicants only took possession of the carport in around May or June 2020, when they fitted a lock and built a false wall, so they had to rely on earlier occupiers to make up the twelve years and could not [1].
- Their own house had been repossessed and left empty from about 2015 to early 2019, breaking any chain of possession [1].
- Dated photographs decided the timing; vague neighbour statements and hearsay were given no weight [1].
- The application was cancelled for the carport only; the garden area behind the applicants' house was not in dispute [1].
The dispute: a carport behind two terraced houses in Batley
Mr and Mrs Holmes own 1 Upper Croft Road, Batley, West Yorkshire, an end-of-terrace house on the corner of Healey Lane and Upper Croft Road, bought in 2019. Mr O'Hara and Miss Hartley own the next house in the terrace, 10 Healey Lane, bought in 2017. An access road runs behind the terrace [1].
The Holmeses applied for first registration, by adverse possession, of two pieces of land: a garden area directly behind their own house and a carport structure located behind the respondents' house. The respondents objected only to the carport, so the Tribunal dealt with the carport alone [1].
Judge Robert Brown heard the case on 29 September 2026 in Leeds after a site inspection on 24 September 2026. Both sides represented themselves; the second applicant and the first respondent gave evidence and cross-examined each other [1].
Why the rear land was not on either title plan
According to the title plans, each registered title extended at the rear only as far as the back wall of the house. Everything behind the houses, including the garden area and the carport, was unregistered land [1].
Adverse possession unregistered land twelve years: the test the applicants had to meet
Because the carport was unregistered, the applicants needed to show twelve years' adverse possession. The Tribunal applied the principles from Powell v McFarlane and J A Pye (Oxford) Ltd v Graham: factual possession, meaning exclusive physical control judged by the nature of the land, and an intention to possess and exclude the world at large including the paper owner [1]. Enclosure and locking the only access are among the strongest forms of evidence.
The applicants had nothing to do with the carport before 2019. To reach twelve years they had to add earlier periods of possession by other people, and that is where the claim ran into trouble [1].
Relying on earlier occupiers: why the chain of possession broke
Successive squatters can add their periods together, but only if possession passed from one to the next without a gap. The evidence here showed the opposite:
- The applicants' house had been repossessed by a mortgagee and left empty, in a fairly derelict state, from around 2015 until they bought it in early 2019 [1].
- Before the applicants' works, the carport's street-facing door was an unlocked up-and-over door, so nobody was excluding anyone [1].
- The house itself needed renovation when bought; there was no central heating and wall ties had to be reinstated [1].
The Tribunal found that the applicants took possession in around May or June 2020, when Mr Holmes built a false wall at the back next to the wall of 10 Healey Lane and replaced the up-and-over door with two hinged doors secured by a lock [1]. From that point their possession was clear. Before it, there was no continuous chain of possession to inherit.
Photographs, floorplans and hearsay: what the Tribunal did and did not accept
The decision is a short lesson in evidence.
Where the two witnesses differed on timing, the judge preferred Mr O'Hara's account as more detailed and supported by photographs [1].
A dated photograph beat a confident recollection. That is the single most useful sentence any homeowner can take from this decision.
What the Tribunal decided, and the 'another six years' point
The application was cancelled insofar as it related to the carport, because adverse possession could not be shown before mid-2020 [1]. The judge acknowledged the applicants had been in possession for over six years, that the paper title owner did not appear to be identifiable, and that the respondents had not demonstrated any right of access to the carport. None of that changed the result: that is not how adverse possession works. If the applicants wish to claim title, they will need to remain in possession for another six years [1]. Both parties indicated they were unlikely to pursue costs [1].
Lessons for Manchester terraces, back yards and ginnels
Swap Batley for Levenshulme, Eccles or Edgeley and the facts could be identical. Points for northern homeowners:
- Check the title plan before you buy. If the rear boundary stops at the back wall, the yard, outhouse or carport may be unregistered.
- Repossessions and empty houses break chains. A property that stood empty for years cannot pass on possession it did not have.
- Lock it, enclose it, date it. The acts that started the clock in Holmes v O'Hara were a lock and a wall, recorded in photographs.
- Neighbours' say-so is not evidence. If a neighbour knows something useful, they need to give a specific statement and be prepared to attend.
Expert evidence: how a chartered surveyor's boundary report, measured plan and dated photographs make or break these claims
Both parties in Holmes v O'Hara acted for themselves, and the outcome turned on which of them had better-dated photographs. A chartered surveyor acting as an expert witness brings structure to exactly that problem:
- A measured survey plotting the carport, walls, doors and gutters against both registered titles.
- A dated chronology of physical changes, drawing on site inspection, historic photographs, sales listings and aerial imagery, to fix when enclosure began.
- An explanation of the general boundaries rule, so the title plan is read correctly.
- An impartial opinion on whether the physical evidence supports exclusive control.
For how surveyors document physical evidence in neighbour disputes, see Building Survey Evidence in Boundary Disputes 2026.
Buying a house where land is used but not owned: what your surveyor and conveyancer should check
Here the applicants' surveyor found a 2015 floorplan showing the carport, yet the 2019 listing made no mention of it [1]. That kind of discrepancy should prompt questions before exchange: does the registered extent match what the seller says comes with the house, is any yard or carport unregistered and who has used it, and what rights exist over shared access roads or ginnels?
A conveyancer can raise enquiries; a surveyor can inspect, measure and record. HM Land Registry's practice guides on adverse possession of unregistered land and on general boundaries explain the framework the Tribunal applies [2][3].
How Manchester Surveyors can help
Manchester Surveyors is an RICS practice serving Manchester, Salford, Stockport, Trafford and the wider North West. Its chartered surveyors prepare measured boundary surveys, boundary dispute reports and expert witness evidence for tribunal and court proceedings, alongside building surveys and valuations.
FAQ
Why did the applicants need twelve years rather than ten?
The carport was unregistered land, so the Limitation Act 1980 period of twelve years applied. Registered land is dealt with under Schedule 6 to the Land Registration Act 2002, which uses a ten-year period and a different procedure [1][2].
Can earlier occupiers' time count towards adverse possession?
Yes, but only if possession passed from one occupier to the next without a gap. In Holmes v O'Hara the applicants' house had been repossessed and left empty for years, so there was no continuous chain [1].
Why were the neighbour statements ignored?
The written statement was vague and did not distinguish the garden from the carport, and the other accounts were hearsay from people who were not called to give evidence [1].
Does this mean the applicants can never own the carport?
No. The judge said that if they wish to claim title they will need to remain in possession for another six years [1].
Conclusion
Holmes v O'Hara (2026) UKFTT 1514 (PC) is a modest case with a sharp message about adverse possession unregistered land twelve years: the clock starts when exclusive control begins, it cannot be borrowed from an empty house, and it is proved with dated photographs rather than neighbourly recollection [1]. For Manchester and northern homeowners the practical steps are to check the registered extent before buying, to record enclosure and locking with dated evidence, and to involve a chartered surveyor early when a yard, carport or ginnel is used but not owned. The Holmeses may yet succeed in 2032; better evidence and earlier advice might have changed the picture sooner.
References
- Holmes v O'Hara and another (2026) UKFTT 1514 (PC), First-tier Tribunal (Property Chamber), decision of 15 October 2026, Find Case Law, The National Archives. caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk.
- HM Land Registry, Practice guide 5: adverse possession of unregistered land and of registered land where a right to be registered was acquired before 13 October 2003. gov.uk.
- HM Land Registry, Practice guide 40, supplement 3: land registry plans, boundaries. gov.uk.