Since 1 November 2026 every RICS Registered Valuer carrying out a mortgage valuation on a flat in a multi-storey building has had to work to a new rulebook. The second edition of the RICS professional standard Secured lending valuation in multi-storey, multi-occupancy residential buildings with cladding took effect on that date, and it changes when a cladding valuation EWS1 request is justified, what can be accepted instead, and how valuers should explain their reasoning [1][2]. For Manchester, where city-centre, Salford Quays and Ancoats apartment blocks have carried EWS1 questions through every sale and remortgage since 2017, the practical consequences are significant.
Key Takeaways
- The RICS standard, 2nd edition, was published on 12 May 2026 and became effective on 1 November 2026, superseding the first edition [1][2].
- Its stated aim is to cut unnecessary EWS1 requests while still flagging external wall issues that could affect value or marketability [2].
- Valuers must use proportionate criteria and an EWS1 decision tree, and should "always have a rationale to justify the request for an EWS1 form" [1].
- In certain cases a PAS 9980 fire risk appraisal summary can be accepted instead of an EWS1 [2].
- The EWS1 "is not a safety certificate" and does not replace a fire risk assessment [1][2].
What the new cladding valuation EWS1 standard says
The standard applies to RICS members and regulated firms carrying out secured lending valuations, which include mortgage valuations, of flats in residential and mixed-use buildings across the UK [1][2]. It followed consultation with fire safety professionals, valuers, insurers and lenders, and was designed to make valuation risk assessment more consistent [2].
Three features matter most for a Manchester flat owner or buyer.
A rationale for every EWS1 request
Under the second edition a valuer should "always have a rationale to justify the request for an EWS1 form" [1]. The standard provides proportionate criteria and an EWS1 decision tree based on building height and construction features, such as visible cladding, curtain walling and certain balcony designs [2]. The criteria are guidance rather than a mechanical test, and professional judgement still applies [1].
PAS 9980 as an alternative
In certain cases a PAS 9980 fire risk appraisal summary or executive summary may be accepted instead of an EWS1, provided it clearly states whether remedial works are required and has been completed by a suitably qualified professional [2]. For buildings that already hold a PAS 9980 appraisal, this can remove a step that previously stalled transactions.
What the EWS1 is not
The standard is explicit that the EWS1 "is not a safety certificate" [1]. It exists for valuation and lending purposes only and is not a substitute for a professional life-safety fire risk assessment. A building that does not need an EWS1 is not thereby guaranteed never to need remediation, and buyers and their legal advisers are advised to review the building's fire risk assessment during a purchase [1][2].
"Mortgage valuations must give lenders and borrowers clear and proportionate advice.", Nigel Sellars, RICS senior specialist for residential valuation [2]
Mr Sellars added that the standard gives practical criteria for when further cladding information is needed, helping to reduce unnecessary EWS1 requests while still considering material risks to value [2].
When a Manchester valuer will and will not ask for an EWS1
The second edition does not abolish the EWS1. It narrows the circumstances in which a valuer should ask for one and requires the request to be explained. In broad terms:
Every case turns on the building, so sellers should not assume the outcome. What has changed is that a blanket EWS1 request without a documented reason no longer meets the standard.
What leaseholders, buyers and sellers in Manchester should prepare
Transactions involving flats in Manchester's post-2000 apartment stock move faster when the building safety information is ready before the valuer visits. Sellers and managing agents should assemble:
- The current fire risk assessment for the building.
- Any existing EWS1 form and its date.
- Any PAS 9980 fire risk appraisal, including the executive summary stating whether remedial works are required.
- Information on remediation funding, programme and completion.
- Building height, storey count and a description of the external wall construction and balconies.
- Service charge and reserve fund information relating to fire safety works.
Buyers who commission their own Manchester valuation report alongside the lender's valuation obtain an independent view of how the building's position affects value, which is useful if the lender's figure comes in low.
Down-valuations and how to challenge them
A down-valuation occurs when the lender's valuer reports a market value below the agreed purchase price. Cladding and EWS1 uncertainty has been one of the most common triggers in Manchester's apartment market, and the new standard is intended to reduce the number of cases where uncertainty alone drives the figure down [2].
Where a down-valuation does happen, a buyer has three main options:
- Ask the lender to reconsider. Most lenders will look again if the buyer supplies comparable evidence of recent sales in the same or similar blocks, together with the building safety documents listed above.
- Obtain an independent RICS Red Book valuation. Mortgage valuations are carried out under the RICS Valuation, Global Standards (the Red Book) and the UK national supplement. An independent Registered Valuer's report can test whether the lender's valuer applied the cladding standard correctly.
- Switch lender. Different lenders use different panel valuers and have different risk appetites for cladding-affected buildings.
A step-by-step guide is available at how to challenge a building survey valuation in the UK without jeopardising your mortgage offer.
Valuation disputes, negligence claims and expert evidence
Not every disagreement ends with a revised figure. Where a valuation is alleged to have been negligent, the claimant must show that the figure fell outside the range a reasonably competent valuer would have reached. In those claims, and in other valuation disputes, RICS Registered Valuers act as expert witnesses under Part 35 of the Civil Procedure Rules, which gives the expert an overriding duty to the court and requires a statement of truth.
A further change arrives on 30 November 2026, when the RICS professional standard Surveyors acting as expert witnesses (5th edition, published 30 July 2026) takes effect [3]. Among other things it requires expert valuers to disclose any use of AI in preparing evidence, to disclose financial dependence on an instructing party, to include mandatory declarations in their reports and to keep a strict separation between the expert role and advocacy [3]. For cladding-related valuation disputes, that means an expert's treatment of the EWS1 decision tree and the PAS 9980 alternative will need to be set out transparently, with alternative conclusions where the building facts are in dispute.
Guidance on choosing the right expert is available at expert witness surveyor vs structural engineer: who to instruct for defect and valuation disputes.
Frequently asked questions
Does the new standard mean my Manchester flat no longer needs an EWS1?
Not necessarily. The standard narrows when an EWS1 should be requested and requires the valuer to record a rationale, but taller blocks with relevant external wall features may still need one or a PAS 9980 alternative [1][2].
Is an EWS1 proof that my building is safe?
No. The standard states the EWS1 "is not a safety certificate" and is not a substitute for a fire risk assessment [1].
What should I do if the lender's valuation comes in below my offer?
Provide comparable evidence and building safety documents to the lender, consider an independent Red Book valuation, and if necessary approach another lender.
Conclusion
The second edition of the RICS secured lending cladding standard, in force since 1 November 2026, asks valuers to be proportionate, to justify every cladding valuation EWS1 request, and to accept PAS 9980 appraisals where appropriate [1][2]. For Manchester flat owners the practical next steps are to gather the building's fire safety documents before marketing, to use an independent Red Book valuation if a down-valuation occurs, and to understand that disputes which reach court will be decided on expert evidence prepared under the RICS expert witness standard from 30 November 2026 [3]. This article is general information rather than legal or financial advice; anyone facing a live valuation dispute should take professional advice.
References
- Valuation of Properties in Multi Storey Multi Occupancy Residential Buildings with Cladding. rics.org.
- Rics Releases Updated Guidance on Home Valuations. propertyindustryeye.com.
- Surveyors Acting as Expert Witnesses. rics.org.