Building Liability Orders After Crest Nicholson v Ardmore [2026] EWHC 789 (TCC): What the £14.9m Adjudication Ruling Means for Manchester Defect Claims and Expert Evidence (November 2026)

{"content":[]}

A contractor goes into administration on 28 August 2025. The next day an adjudicator orders it to pay roughly £14.9 million for defective external walls. On paper, that money looks lost. In Crest Nicholson Regeneration Ltd v Ardmore Construction Ltd (in administration) [2026] EWHC 789 (TCC), the Technology and Construction Court showed that it need not be [1]. For anyone considering a building liability order defects claim Manchester-wide, the judgment is the most important reading of the year. It confirms that the Building Safety Act 2022 can reach past an insolvent contractor to the companies standing behind it, and it sets out how the courts will decide when that is fair.

This article explains the ruling, what a building liability order (BLO) is, why it matters for Manchester's stock of 2000s apartment buildings, and the expert evidence such claims depend on. It is general information, not legal advice.

Key Takeaways

  • The TCC granted both an anticipatory BLO and a BLO enforcing a c.£14.9m adjudicator's decision against companies associated with Ardmore Construction Ltd [1][2].
  • An adjudicator's decision can be a "relevant liability" under section 130 of the Building Safety Act 2022, even though it is only temporarily binding [3].
  • The "just and equitable" test is broad and fact-sensitive, and the court declined to lay down an exhaustive list of factors [2].
  • Partial BLOs are permissible, and prematurity is weighed inside the just-and-equitable assessment rather than treated as a separate bar [2].
  • Expert evidence on external walls and fire compartmentation sits at the centre of these claims; the RICS expert witness standard changes on 30 November 2026 [4][5].

What Is a Building Liability Order?

Sections 130 to 132 of the Building Safety Act 2022 created a new tool for the High Court [6]. A BLO allows the court to make a company that is "associated" with the original wrongdoer jointly and severally liable for a "relevant liability". A relevant liability is one arising under the Defective Premises Act 1972, section 38 of the Building Act 1984, or as a result of a building safety risk.

Two companies are associated where one controls the other, or where a third company controls both. Section 132 adds information orders, which compel a company to disclose details of its associates so that a claimant can identify who to pursue.

Before this year, the only reported example of a BLO being made was 381 Southwark Park Road RTM Co Ltd v Click St Andrews Ltd [2024] [3]. Crest Nicholson v Ardmore is the second, and it goes considerably further.

The Facts Behind the Building Liability Order Defects Claim

Admiralty Quarter is a residential development in Portsmouth, completed between 2007 and 2009. Ardmore Construction Ltd (ACL) was the design and build contractor under a JCT 1998 With Contractor's Design form [1]. Crest Nicholson alleged fire safety defects in the external wall systems and the internal fire compartmentation.

Crest referred the external wall defects to adjudication. On 29 August 2025, the adjudicator found that ACL was in breach of contract and of its duty under section 1 of the Defective Premises Act 1972, and decided that ACL should pay about £14,928,320 [1]. The decision was not paid.

ACL had entered administration on 28 August 2025, the day before. Mr Justice Constable accepted that the timing was coincidental, but found that the administration was driven wholly or in significant part by ACL's exposure to building safety claims after Grenfell [1][2]. The court also found that the group had been restructured to ring-fence ACL's liabilities, with ultimate control resting with Cormac Byrne and his family trust. ACL reported spending over £100 million on remedial work across its projects, with £75 million agreed with its principal insurers [1].

Crest applied for two orders against companies in the Ardmore group:

  1. An anticipatory BLO, making the associated companies jointly and severally liable for any future liability of ACL under section 1 of the Defective Premises Act 1972 or arising from a building safety risk.
  2. An adjudication BLO, making the associated companies jointly and severally liable for the c.£14.9m adjudication sum.

The hearing took place on 2 to 4 March 2026 and judgment was handed down on 1 April 2026 [1].

What the Court Decided

The court granted both orders [2][3]. The reasoning will shape every building liability order defects claim Manchester owners and developers bring from here on.

Issue What the TCC held
Can a BLO be made before liability is finally proved? Yes. Anticipatory BLOs are available; the court agreed with HHJ Keyser KC's reasoning in BDW v Ardmore [2].
Is an adjudicator's decision a "relevant liability"? Yes, even though it is only temporarily binding. Failure to comply with the decision can itself be a relevant liability [3].
What does "just and equitable" require? A broad, fact-sensitive assessment. The court declined to set an exhaustive list of factors [2].
Is an application premature if trial is pending? Prematurity is folded into the just-and-equitable assessment, weighed against how likely the order is to survive trial [2].
Must the BLO mirror the whole liability? No. Partial BLOs are permissible [2].
Does it matter that the claimant is a commercial developer? Little weight. Crest's status and the parties' comparative profits were given little weight [2][3].

The purpose of section 130 is wider than funding remediation: it is to ensure that those responsible for building safety defects pay for them (the court's reasoning as summarised by Pump Court Chambers [2]).

The factors that weighed in Crest's favour included ACL's insolvency, the restructuring that isolated historic liabilities, common control across the group, a strong prima facie case of serious defects, and the purpose of the Act [2]. The court had a high degree of confidence that the external walls posed a building safety risk and that ACL would be liable in some measure, although liability and quantum still require trial [1]. The defendants have indicated an intention to appeal [2].

How Adjudication Interacts With a BLO

Adjudication gives a quick, temporarily binding decision. Many assumed a claimant would need to convert it into a court judgment before it could count as a relevant liability. Crest Nicholson v Ardmore removes that step [3]. That matters in three ways:

  • Speed. A claimant can adjudicate, then apply for a BLO against the associates without first obtaining summary judgment.
  • Protection against overpayment. If a trial later finds the adjudicator awarded too much, the associates can seek restitution; Crest offered an undertaking to cover any overpayment [3].
  • Two-stage anticipatory orders. The anticipatory BLO fixes the principle now; a second stage converts it into an enforceable order once liability is quantified, when the court can reassess relative blameworthiness and reduce the associates' share [3].

Why This Matters for a Building Liability Order Defects Claim Manchester-Wide

Manchester saw a wave of apartment construction in the late 1990s and 2000s. Salford Quays, Ancoats and the city centre gained large residential blocks in the same period as Admiralty Quarter, many delivered by design and build contractors under JCT forms, with external wall systems and compartmentation details that have since come under scrutiny. Several features of the ruling are directly relevant:

  • Contractor insolvency is no longer the end of the road. The court can look through to associated companies [1][2].
  • The limitation window is long. The Act extended limitation for Defective Premises Act claims to 30 years retrospectively, so 2000s buildings remain in play [6].
  • Freeholders, management companies and developers can all apply. Crest's status as a commercial developer carried little weight [2].
  • Information orders unlock group structures. Section 132 lets a claimant identify the associates before committing to a full claim [6].

Expert Evidence in Building Safety Defect Claims

No BLO application succeeds without a credible technical case. In Crest Nicholson v Ardmore, the court's confidence that the external walls posed a building safety risk was central to the "just and equitable" finding [1].

What the expert work involves

  • External wall investigations: opening-up works to identify cladding, insulation, cavity barriers and fixings, with testing where needed.
  • Fire compartmentation surveys: fire doors, service penetrations, cavity closers and compartment walls.
  • Defect schedules: linking each defect to the contract documents and the Building Regulations in force at the time.
  • Remedial scope and cost: quantity surveying evidence supporting the sum claimed.

Duties under CPR Part 35

Experts owe an overriding duty to the court, not to the party paying them (CPR 35.3) [5]. Reports must comply with Practice Direction 35, including a statement of truth. Where experts of like discipline disagree, the court will usually order discussions under CPR 35.12 and a joint statement. Reports used in adjudication are often reused in court, so they should meet Part 35 standards from the outset.

The RICS standard changes on 30 November 2026

The fifth edition of the RICS professional standard Surveyors acting as expert witnesses takes effect on 30 November 2026 [4]. Surveyors preparing defect reports for adjudication or BLO applications should align their engagement terms, declarations and report formats with the new edition.

Joint management of TCC and tribunal claims

Building safety disputes increasingly run in the TCC and the First-tier Tribunal at once. In Wallace Estates Ltd v Durkan Estates Ltd [2026] EWHC 2133 (TCC), a joint judgment of the TCC and the President of the First-tier Tribunal directed that both sets of proceedings be heard together, with a single set of expert evidence in architecture, fire engineering and quantity surveying, all governed by CPR Part 35 [7]. A Manchester defects claim should plan its expert evidence to serve both forums.

Manchester Surveyors carries out defect investigations and prepares expert reports for adjudication, tribunal and court proceedings across Greater Manchester.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can a leaseholder apply for a building liability order?
Yes. Section 130 does not limit applicants to developers. Leaseholders, right-to-manage companies, freeholders and developers can all apply where a relevant liability exists [6].

What is the first practical step?
A professional external wall or compartmentation survey to establish whether a building safety risk exists, followed by legal advice on limitation, adjudication and any information order application.

Conclusion

Crest Nicholson v Ardmore [2026] EWHC 789 (TCC) confirms that the Building Safety Act 2022 has real teeth. An adjudicator's decision can ground a BLO, anticipatory orders are available, and group restructuring will not shield associated companies where an order is just and equitable [1][2][3]. For a building liability order defects claim Manchester owners may be weighing up, the lesson is to start with the evidence. Next steps:

  1. Identify the original contractor and check its current corporate status.
  2. Commission an external wall and compartmentation investigation.
  3. Consider a section 132 information order to map the corporate group.
  4. Take legal advice on adjudication, the TCC and the First-tier Tribunal before the RICS expert witness standard changes on 30 November 2026.

This article is general information only and does not constitute legal advice.

References

  1. Crest Nicholson Regeneration Ltd & Ors v Ardmore Construction Ltd (in Administration) & Ors [2026] EWHC 789 (TCC), The National Archives Find Case Law. caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk.
  2. Crest Nicholson v Ardmore [2026] EWHC 789 (TCC): A Landmark Decision on Building Liability Orders, Pump Court Chambers, 2026. pumpcourtchambers.com.
  3. TCC allows Building Liability Order based on an Adjudicator's Decision and an 'Anticipatory' Building Liability Order, Charles Russell Speechlys, 2026. charlesrussellspeechlys.com.
  4. Surveyors acting as expert witnesses, 5th edition, RICS, 2026. rics.org.
  5. Civil Procedure Rules Part 35: Experts and Assessors, Ministry of Justice. justice.gov.uk.
  6. Building Safety Act 2022, legislation.gov.uk. legislation.gov.uk.
  7. Wallace Estates Ltd v Durkan Estates Ltd & Anor [2026] EWHC 2133 (TCC), The National Archives Find Case Law. caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk.

Get a Free Quote

Tell us about your property and we will come back with a fixed-fee quote, fast.

Scroll to Top