{"content":[]}
A 16-storey hotel stood empty from 29 July 2025 because of what was behind its facade, and the court later held that closing it was a reasonable thing to do. That finding rested heavily on expert evidence. For anyone instructing a cladding defect expert witness in Manchester, the judgment in Essendi UK Hotels 2 Ltd v London Property Company Ltd is one of the clearest recent guides to how a Technology and Construction Court (TCC) judge weighs competing fire safety opinions [1].
Updated 19 November 2026. This article is general information, not legal advice.
Key Takeaways
- The TCC held that a landlord's covenant to keep the structure and exterior in good condition required it to remove and replace combustible ACM cladding, even though nothing had physically deteriorated [1].
- Both fire safety experts agreed the cladding posed an intolerable risk. They disagreed on timing and on whether temporary measures could keep the hotel open [1].
- The judge preferred the more cautious expert on the key issues, and criticised the other for assuming mitigation would work without testing whether it was practical [1].
- The landlord was ordered to remove the panels within 6 months and finish replacement within 18 months overall [1].
Key facts of the case at a glance
The case is a commercial lease dispute about who must fix dangerous cladding, decided in the tenant's favour on two of three grounds.
The lease, which followed a sale and leaseback, moved responsibility for the structure and exterior, including the cladding, to the landlord after a cut-off date of 22 May 2017. The Grenfell Tower fire happened on 14 June 2017 [1].
On 7 May 2025 the London Fire Brigade issued a Fire Safety Deficiencies Notification. It recorded that remediation of the cladding had not been planned or organised and set a deadline of 6 May 2026. It was not a formal enforcement or prohibition notice [1]. Essendi closed the hotel with effect from 29 July 2025, after taking advice from its fire safety expert [1].
What the court decided about the cladding
The court decided that the landlord had to strip and replace the cladding, and that the tenant could claim damages for the closure.
The judge reached that result by two separate routes [1]:
- Good condition covenant. The landlord had promised to keep the structure and exterior in good and substantial repair and condition. The judge held that leaving category 3 ACM panels on the building was a breach of that promise.
- Legal obligations covenant. The landlord was also in breach, independently, of its duties under the Regulatory Reform (Fire Safety) Order 2005, which the lease required it to meet.
A third claim, derogation from grant, failed [1]. The judge also found that Essendi did not know, and should not have known before the cut-off date, that the panels were category 3 ACM [1].
Mishcon de Reya notes that the court set no general rule for every repairing covenant, and that the landlord has permission to appeal on several grounds [2].
How the cladding defect expert witness evidence was treated
The judge found all four experts knowledgeable and fair-minded, but on the questions that decided the case he preferred the fire safety expert who took the more cautious approach.
Two pairs of experts
Each side called a cladding expert and a fire safety expert [1]:
The cladding evidence dealt mainly with what the construction sector knew about ACM in 2006. The landlord's own cladding expert accepted in cross-examination that awareness of the specific risks of these panels was far from universal among designers at that time [1].
Where the fire experts agreed
The fire safety experts agreed that the wall as built presented an intolerable risk when assessed on PAS 9980 principles, and that PAS 9980 could be applied by analogy to a hotel. They also agreed that removing the polyethylene-cored panels was the only permanent remedy [1].
A joint inspection in October 2025 confirmed that the panels were present throughout the building [1].
Where they disagreed, and why one was preferred
The dispute was about time and about stopgaps. The landlord's expert thought temporary mitigation could keep the hotel trading while the works went ahead. The tenant's expert doubted that [1].
The judge said he could not confidently prefer one expert on every point. On the key issues, though, he preferred Mr Bullock. His reasons are instructive [1]:
- Mr Bullock's approach was conservative, which the judge thought was right for a fire risk assessment of a hotel where a serious fire could break out at night among guests who did not know the building.
- Mr Van Gorp took a more technical line but, in the judge's view, tended to minimise the risk.
- Mr Van Gorp assumed further mitigation measures would work without looking into whether they were practical, what they would cost or how long they would take.
- In cross-examination he stretched an opinion in his report about what hotel operators knew. The judge held that the wider opinion had no solid evidential basis and went beyond his expertise.
Mr Bullock was not immune from criticism, and had to withdraw or qualify some points [1]. The judge still accepted that Essendi reasonably relied on his advice when it closed the hotel.
The consultant who was not called as an expert
Essendi's own fire engineering consultant, who had advised before the claim, was not called as an expert. The judge noted the risk of such a witness becoming an impermissible second quasi-expert [1].
What this means for Manchester owners, landlords and solicitors
The practical message is that clear lease wording and well-tested expert evidence can settle who pays for a cladding defect, even outside the Building Safety Act regime.
HHJ Stephen Davies heard this case in London, but he is listed by the judiciary as a judge of the TCC in Manchester [3]. Useful lessons include:
- Read the repairing covenant closely. Words such as "condition" can reach further than "repair". Commercial landlords of hotels, offices and student blocks in Greater Manchester should check what they have promised.
- Record the building as it is. Opening-up and a careful record by a chartered building surveyor or facade specialist give experts firm ground.
- Choose the right discipline. The court heard separate cladding and fire safety experts. A building surveyor can report on construction, condition and the history of the works, but fire risk opinions belong to a fire engineer.
- Test every mitigation. If an expert says a temporary measure will do, the report should explain how it would work in practice and how long it would take.
- Keep advisers and experts apart. The person who advised before the dispute is usually a witness of fact. An independent expert under CPR Part 35 should give the opinion evidence.
- Act on regulator letters. The fire brigade's notification carried weight even though it was not a formal enforcement notice [1].
What happens next in the case
The case is not over: damages, costs and a possible appeal all remain.
On 2 October 2026 the same judge ruled that he could be told the date of the landlord's first Part 36 offer before deciding costs, because the date is not one of the offer's terms [4]. Damages for the closure will be assessed separately unless the parties settle [1]. Mishcon de Reya reports that a quantum trial is expected in late 2027 [2].
FAQ
What is a cladding defect expert witness?
A cladding defect expert witness is an independent specialist who gives opinion evidence to a court or tribunal about an external wall. The expert may be a facade consultant, building surveyor or fire engineer. The overriding duty is to the court, not to the party paying the fee.
Did the court say every landlord must replace unsafe cladding?
No. The decision turned on the words of this lease and its commercial setting. Mishcon de Reya notes that the court set no general rule for all repairing covenants [2]. Each lease must be read on its own terms.
Why did the judge prefer one fire expert over the other?
The judge thought a cautious approach suited a hotel with sleeping guests. He found that the landlord's expert tended to play down the risk and assumed mitigation would work without checking its practicality [1].
Conclusion
Essendi shows that a cladding dispute can turn on how carefully the experts have done their work. The expert whose opinion was cautious, practical and kept within his field was preferred.
Manchester owners and landlords should review their repairing covenants now, gather a reliable record of the external wall, and instruct independent experts in the correct disciplines before positions harden. Solicitors should watch for the outcome of any appeal and for the damages hearing.
References
- Essendi UK Hotels 2 Limited v London Property Company Limited [2026] EWHC 1354 (TCC), The National Archives. caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk.
- Mishcon de Reya, Landlord ordered to strip flammable ACM cladding from a 16-storey Wembley hotel (22 September 2026). mishcon.com.
- Courts and Tribunals Judiciary, The Technology and Construction Court in Manchester. judiciary.uk.
- Essendi UK Hotels 2 Limited v London Property Company Limited (Preliminary issue Part 36 CPR) [2026] EWHC 2501 (TCC), The National Archives. caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk.