A 260-page decision handed down at Manchester Civil Justice Centre on 5 November 2026 has put a figure of £46,500,650 on one developer's responsibility for fire-safety defects in seven city-centre buildings. The Urban Splash remediation contribution order is the largest of its kind reported so far, and it lands on the desks of Manchester leaseholders, managing agents and building owners at the same moment they are deciding how to evidence their own defect claims [1][2].
This article explains what the First-tier Tribunal decided, why the "just and equitable" test under section 124 of the Building Safety Act 2022 mattered, and what the ruling means for the expert and surveyor evidence that sits behind every remediation claim in Greater Manchester.
Key Takeaways
- On 5 November 2026 the First-tier Tribunal (Property Chamber) made remediation contribution orders totalling £46,500,650 against five Urban Splash companies, jointly and severally, in favour of the Secretary of State and Moho Management Company Ltd [1][2].
- The orders cover seven Manchester buildings developed around 2000 to 2008: Burton Place, the Chips Building, the Moho Building, The Box Works and the three Dalton Street "Three Towers" [2].
- The tribunal found remediation costs of £60,638,548 including VAT were reasonably incurred, reduced the publicly funded element by 10% to reflect wider government contributions, and stressed this was not a finding that government caused 10% of the defects [2].
- Judge Holbrook said there was a "powerful case" for the developer "rather than the taxpayer, to bear the remediation costs" [1].
- Intrusive investigations, external wall surveys and independent expert reports are the backbone of these claims, and surveyors giving evidence must meet strict independence duties.
What the Urban Splash remediation contribution order decided
The application was brought by the Secretary of State for Housing, Communities and Local Government. The panel was Judge J Holbrook, Regional Judge N Walsh and Mr A Gee RIBA. Hearings ran from 27 April to 15 May 2026 and again from 8 June to 1 July 2026, and the decision is reported as [2026] UKFTT 01426 (PC) [2].
The tribunal made remediation contribution orders under section 124 of the Building Safety Act 2022 against Urban Splash Limited, Urban Splash Developments Limited, Urban Splash Group Holdings Limited, Urban Splash Work Limited and Stubbs Mill LLP. The orders are joint and several, so the government can pursue any one of the companies for the full sum. Of the £46,500,650 ordered, £741,594 is payable to Moho Management Company Ltd and the balance to the Secretary of State [2].
No orders were made against four other respondents, and applications against two more were withdrawn after settlement [2].
The buildings and the defects
The seven buildings are all well known in Manchester: Burton Place, the Chips Building in New Islington, the Moho Building in Castlefield, The Box Works, and the three Dalton Street blocks known as the Three Towers (Emmeline House, Christabel House and Sylvia House). They were developed roughly between 2000 and 2008 [2].
The tribunal found each building had fire-safety-related defects discovered in inspections after the Grenfell Tower fire. These included combinations of combustible materials and ineffective cavity barriers [1]. Reporting on the decision also referred to fire-stopping and compartmentation problems [2].
How the £46.5m figure was reached
The 10% reduction reflected government contributions to the wider building-safety crisis. The tribunal was careful to say this was not a finding that the government was responsible for 10% of the defects or the remediation costs [2]. Other adjustments included an earlier settlement.
Why the "just and equitable" test went against the developer
Section 124 allows the tribunal to order a developer, landlord or associated company to contribute to the cost of remedying relevant defects where it is "just and equitable" to do so. The Urban Splash companies no longer owned the buildings when the works were done, and no Building Safety Fund money was paid to them [1]. That did not save them.
"There is a powerful case for the developer, rather than the taxpayer, to bear the remediation costs." – Judge Holbrook, as reported [1]
The judge accepted that Urban Splash gave "useful and responsible assistance" with post-Grenfell investigations, but drew an "important distinction" between assisting those investigations and accepting financial responsibility for the resulting remediation [1].
Urban Splash said it was reviewing the decision and taking legal advice, that the liability was "significant for a business of our size", and that it wanted "a constructive way forward with government". A spokesperson described the Act's reach as having "far-reaching consequences" [1][2].
Where this sits in Building Safety Act case law
The Urban Splash remediation contribution order follows a line of decisions that have steadily widened the reach of section 124. The Court of Appeal in Triathlon Homes v Stratford Village Development Partnership confirmed that orders can reach costs incurred before the section came into force, and the Vista Tower litigation confirmed that respondents' appeals will not succeed simply because the sums are large [3].
What is new here is scale and detail. A 260-page decision, a panel including an architect member, and a line-by-line assessment of what was reasonably spent give future applicants a template. It also tells developers that cooperation with investigations is welcome but is not a defence to contribution.
The expert evidence behind a remediation contribution order
A remediation contribution order is only as strong as the technical evidence underneath it. The tribunal must be satisfied that defects are "relevant defects", that the works were needed, and that the costs were reasonable. That is surveying and fire-engineering territory.
What the evidence usually looks like
- Intrusive investigations opening up external walls, cavities and compartment lines to establish what was actually built, rather than what the drawings show.
- External wall surveys and PAS 9980 fire risk appraisals which assess the external wall system as a whole and state whether remediation is required.
- Fire-engineering reports on cavity barriers, fire stopping and compartmentation, often with photographs of every opening.
- Cost evidence from quantity surveyors on tendered and actual remediation spend, with any betterment separated out.
- Chronology evidence showing when defects were found, who was told and when funding was sought.
The presence of Mr A Gee RIBA on the panel is a reminder that tribunals expect technical arguments to be tested by people who understand construction. Vague or partisan reports do not survive that scrutiny.
Independence duties for surveyors acting as expert witnesses
Building surveyors and fire engineers who give evidence in these applications owe their primary duty to the tribunal, not to the party paying them. The principles in CPR Part 35 and Practice Direction 35 apply in the courts, and tribunals expect the same standard: a statement of truth, a clear statement of instructions, and opinions the expert honestly holds.
From 30 November 2026 the RICS professional standard Surveyors acting as expert witnesses, 5th edition, takes effect. It requires disclosure of AI use in preparing evidence, disclosure of heavy reliance on a single instructing party, fuller statements of assumptions and alternative conclusions, and keeps the ban on new conditional fees [4]. Any Manchester surveyor instructed on a remediation claim after that date should be working to the new standard now.
What the ruling means for Manchester leaseholders and building owners
For resident management companies, freeholders and leaseholders in Ancoats, Castlefield, the Northern Quarter and along the Salford border, the practical lessons are clear.
- Evidence first. Commission a proper defect investigation and keep every report, photograph and invoice. A tribunal will want to trace each pound of cost to a defect.
- Identify the right respondents. Section 124 reaches developers and associated companies, not just the current landlord. Group structures do not protect the original developer.
- Watch limitation. The Building Safety Act extended Defective Premises Act 1972 claims to 30 years for dwellings completed before 28 June 2022 and 15 years after. Remediation contribution orders have their own route, but the clock still matters for parallel claims.
- Expect the technical detail to be tested. The tribunal did not simply accept the government's figures; it assessed what was reasonably incurred. Applicants and respondents both need credible experts.
- Schedules of condition and defect evidence packs prepared by an independent chartered surveyor are the cheapest insurance against a dispute about what was there and when.
Frequently asked questions
What is a remediation contribution order?
It is an order made by the First-tier Tribunal under section 124 of the Building Safety Act 2022 requiring a developer, landlord or associated company to contribute to the cost of remedying relevant defects in a relevant building, where the tribunal considers it just and equitable.
Did Urban Splash receive Building Safety Fund money?
No. The buildings were not owned by Urban Splash when the works were carried out and no fund money was paid to the company. The orders require it to reimburse the public purse and Moho Management Company Ltd [1][2].
Can a leaseholder or management company apply for one of these orders?
Yes. Interested persons including leaseholders, resident management companies and the Secretary of State can apply. Technical evidence from independent surveyors and fire engineers is essential.
Conclusion
The Urban Splash remediation contribution order is a landmark for Manchester and for the Building Safety Act. A developer that no longer owned the buildings and never received public funds has been ordered to pay £46.5m because the tribunal found it just and equitable that the developer, not the taxpayer, should bear the cost of fire-safety defects.
For anyone in Greater Manchester living with, managing or advising on a building with suspected defects, the next steps are practical: instruct an independent chartered building surveyor to investigate and document the defects, assemble a chronology and cost evidence pack, identify every potentially liable company in the developer's group, and make sure any expert engaged is working to CPR Part 35 principles and the incoming RICS 5th edition standard. Urban Splash has said it is taking legal advice, so an appeal remains possible, but the evidential standard set by this decision is here to stay.
References
- Developer Told to Pay 45m to Government for Post Grenfell Repairs. itv.com.
- Urban Splash Ruling. planninggeek.co.uk.
- Building Safety Act 2022 Key Court of Appeal Decision as to Whether Remediation Contribution Orders Could Be Made in Respect of Costs Incurred Prior to Commencement of S 124 Bsa 2022. jbleitch.co.uk.
- Surveyors Acting as Expert Witnesses. rics.org.