A block of flats with combustible cladding has not burned down. Is it under a threat of "imminent" damage? On 3 November 2026 the Court of Appeal declined to answer that question on paper and sent it to trial. Vivid Housing Ltd v Allianz Global Corporate & Specialty SE (2026) EWCA Civ 1389 matters to anyone pursuing a cladding defects warranty claim, because it confirms that the answer depends on evidence about the actual building, and much of that evidence comes from surveyors and fire engineers [1].
The appeal was heard on 20 October 2026. Lord Justice Stuart-Smith gave the lead judgment, with Lord Justice Phillips and Lord Justice Peter Jackson agreeing [1].
Key Takeaways
- The insurer's attempt to have most of the claim dismissed without a trial has failed twice.
- Whether fire safety defects amount to a threat of imminent damage is a question of fact and degree.
- A facade fire risk assessment by surveyors, with colour-coded priorities, was the main evidence at this stage.
- The use of a waking watch may itself point towards an imminent threat requiring immediate measures.
- Owners of Manchester blocks with similar policies should check their periods of insurance and notification dates now.
The building and the policy
Vivid Housing is the freeholder of a block of 72 flats at Collins Place, Victoria Road North, Portsmouth. The block is covered by a housing warranty insurance policy issued by Building LifePlans Ltd as cover-holder for Allianz. The period of insurance ran from 22 May 2008 to 21 May 2020. Vivid notified its claim on or about 19 May 2020, two days before cover ended [1].
The alleged defects in the appeal were:
These are allegations at this stage. Nothing has yet been proved at trial.
The clause in dispute
The policy pays the cost of repair following a defect that causes one of three things within the period of insurance: destruction of the premises, physical damage to them, or, in the words of the third limb:
"the threat of imminent destruction or physical damage to the Premises which requires immediate remedial measures" [1]
There had been no fire and no physical damage. So the claim depended on the third limb. Allianz applied for summary judgment, arguing that the claim could not succeed. For the purposes of that application only, it did not rely on a separate fire exclusion in the policy [1].
What the High Court decided
In December 2025, Mrs Justice Jefford in the Technology and Construction Court dismissed the majority of the insurer's application. She applied the test from the earlier case of Gerling v Canary Wharf: is the damage sufficiently likely to happen sufficiently soon? That, she held, is a matter of fact and degree, unsuitable for decision without a trial [1].
The Court of Appeal's reasoning
Allianz appealed on a single ground. It said the judge's approach meant that fire damage would always be "imminent" in any building with fire safety defects, which would strip the word of meaning.
The Court of Appeal disagreed. The judge had asked the right question: whether, at the relevant time, the risk was serious enough and would eventuate soon enough. She had been careful not to reach a concluded view. Lord Justice Stuart-Smith observed that the longer the hearing went on, the less there seemed to be between the parties [1].
Three evidential points stand out.
The claim form was not decisive. When notifying the claim, Vivid had answered "N/A" to a question about urgent repairs. The insurer relied on that. The court held that the wording of a notification does not settle the matter.
The survey evidence was more informative. The main evidence was a Facade Fire Risk Assessment prepared by CBRE, which ranked issues by three colour-coded levels of priority. The cladding panels and workmanship were rated orange. The absence of compartmentation was rated red, the most serious category. The court regarded that prioritisation as much more informative than the claim form [1].
The waking watch cut both ways. A waking watch was in place at the building. The insurer said that showed the risk was being managed. The court said it was at least tenable that adopting a waking watch is itself an immediate remedial measure, which is what the clause requires [1].
The appeal was dismissed. The claim now goes to trial.
Why this matters for a cladding defects warranty claim
The decision does not say that combustible cladding always triggers cover. It says the question cannot be answered in the abstract. At trial, the outcome will turn on evidence such as:
- what materials are on the building and where;
- whether cavity barriers are present, correctly fitted and continuous;
- how a fire would be likely to start and spread;
- how quickly occupants could escape;
- what interim measures were needed and why.
There was no expert evidence under CPR Part 35 at the summary judgment stage. At trial there will be, most likely from fire engineers and facade specialists, with building surveyors on the condition of the as-built construction.
Lessons for Manchester building owners and managers
Greater Manchester has one of the largest concentrations of mid-rise and high-rise residential blocks outside London, and many were built in the same period as Collins Place.
- Find the policy. Many blocks completed in the 2000s and 2010s have a latent defects or housing warranty policy. Check who the insurer is and when the period of insurance ends.
- Notify in time. Vivid notified two days before expiry. A claim notified late may be lost whatever its merits.
- Read the insuring clause. Wording differs between policies. Some require physical damage. Others, like this one, extend to an imminent threat.
- Take care with claim forms. Answers given in a hurry can be used against the claimant years later.
- Record why interim measures were adopted. Minutes, fire service correspondence and risk assessments explaining the reason for a waking watch or alarm upgrade may become evidence.
Lessons for surveyors
- A facade report may be read by a court. Opinions should be reasoned, and priorities should be explained in terms a non-specialist can follow.
- Distinguish clearly between what was observed, what was assumed and what was inferred from limited opening-up.
- Say how urgent each issue is, and why. In this case the urgency ratings carried real weight.
- Know the limits of competence. Fire engineering questions should go to a fire engineer.
Frequently asked questions
Has the court decided that the insurer must pay? No. The Court of Appeal decided only that the claim is arguable and must be tried. Whether the defects exist, and whether they posed an imminent threat, are still to be decided.
Does this apply to every building warranty? No. Each policy has its own wording. The decision is about a clause covering a threat of imminent damage. A policy that pays only for actual physical damage may be treated differently.
Does a waking watch prove an imminent threat? Not by itself. The court said it was arguable that a waking watch is a remedial step. The reason it was put in place, and the advice behind it, will matter.
Conclusion
Vivid Housing v Allianz keeps the door open for warranty claims based on fire safety defects where nothing has yet been damaged. It also shows where such claims will be won or lost: in careful, well-reasoned technical evidence about the real level of risk in the building.
Owners and managing agents of affected blocks should locate their warranty policies, check the key dates, and make sure their facade and fire risk reports are detailed enough to support a claim if one is needed.
References
- Vivid Housing Ltd v Allianz Global Corporate & Specialty SE (2026) EWCA Civ 1389, judgment of 3 November 2026, Find Case Law, The National Archives. caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk.