A terraced house split into two flats, a tenant's complaint about damp and mould, and a list of hazards that took well over a year to clear. The facts of Sheffield City Council v El-Saadawy and another (2026) UKUT 441 (LC) could come from almost any northern city with older rented housing. The decision, given by Martin Rodger KC, Deputy Chamber President of the Upper Tribunal (Lands Chamber), on 13 November 2026, is a careful account of how civil penalties for failing to comply with improvement notices should be assessed. It also shows what a tribunal means by "harm" when a landlord leaves hazards in place.
The case was heard in the northern region of the First-tier Tribunal, the same region that hears Manchester cases. Councils and landlords across Greater Manchester can expect it to be cited.
The property and the hazards
The property is a terraced house in Sheffield, bought by a married couple in 2004 after it had suffered substantial fire damage. They divided it into two flats and let both.
A complaint from the tenant of the lower flat about damp and mould led to a council inspection on 15 December 2022. Under the Housing Health and Safety Rating System, the inspection found category 1 hazards of:
- damp and mould growth;
- excess cold;
- falls on level surfaces;
- falls on stairs;
- fire.
Category 2 hazards were also recorded, covering entry by intruders, hygiene, pests and refuse, and electrical hazards. The upper flat was inspected on 10 January 2023 and showed similar category 1 and category 2 hazards.
The decision gives examples of what lay behind those headings in the lower flat: gaps between the front door and its frame, no insulation between the unheated cellar and the ground floor, an external downpipe discharging into the rear yard and causing ice on the main exit route, and inadequate fire separation in the living areas and along the means of escape. For the upper flat the council pointed to the lack of fire separation following the conversion.
The improvement notices and what followed
Improvement notices were served for both flats in early 2023. For the lower flat, urgent works were required by 5 May 2023 and the remainder by 24 June 2023. For the upper flat, the dates were 24 May and 12 July 2023. The landlords did not appeal either notice and did not ask for more time.
Some urgent items were dealt with promptly, and gas and electrical certificates were provided on time. The rest was not finished:
- on 12 July 2023 both flats were inspected, and category 1 and category 2 hazards remained;
- the upper flat's tenant had left in June 2023, and on 22 August 2023 the flat was found to have been re-let with works still outstanding;
- the lower flat was still incomplete on 12 January 2024;
- the upper flat was found complete on 27 June 2024 and the lower flat on 29 August 2024.
The landlords said they had difficulty getting access from tenants and arranging separation of the electricity supplies, and that the husband had been in poor health.
The penalties
Failing to comply with an improvement notice is an offence under the Housing Act 2004, for which a council may impose a civil penalty instead of prosecuting. Sheffield assessed culpability as medium to high and harm as high under its enforcement policy, giving a starting point of £20,000 for each offence. After adjustments, the final penalties totalled £45,000 across the two landlords and the two flats.
The First-tier Tribunal, which inspected the flats, reduced that sharply on 24 September 2025. It assessed both culpability and harm as medium, took a starting point of £10,000 and applied a single 75% reduction for mitigation. The result was £2,500 for each offence: £10,000 in total, or £5,000 for each landlord.
The council appealed on five grounds.
What the Upper Tribunal decided
Four grounds failed. The First-tier Tribunal was entitled to look at the overall penalty on a couple punished for the same failures, to assess culpability as medium, to decline to add further for aggravating factors already counted, and to apply a single percentage for mitigation without itemising it. The Deputy President commented that the council's own 35% deduction to reflect the couple's joint position was hard to explain on any basis other than instinct.
The fifth ground succeeded: harm.
The Upper Tribunal held that the harm that matters is the harm from the property remaining in a hazardous or inadequate state after the date by which the works should have been done. The First-tier Tribunal had said nothing specific about that. It made no findings on which works were unfinished and gave no reasons for rating harm as medium when the council had rated it high.
Remaking the decision, the Deputy President held that high harm was justified. Multiple category 1 hazards remained after the notices expired, including fire-related ones. Because the landlords had not appealed the notices, they could not dispute that the original defects existed.
Medium culpability with high harm gave a starting point of £15,000. Applying the same 75% reduction produced £3,750 for each offence. Each landlord now pays £7,500 in place of £5,000.
A late attempt by the wife to argue that she should pay nothing, because she was not the one managing the property, was refused. The point had not been raised below, and she had admitted the offence.
What landlords should take from it
The clock that matters starts when the notice expires
Mitigation for effort, illness and difficult tenants reduced the penalty substantially. But the assessment of harm looked at what was still wrong on the compliance date and for how long afterwards. Partial compliance leaves the remaining hazards to be counted.
Appeal or ask for time, do not drift
An improvement notice can be appealed, and a council can be asked to extend time. These landlords did neither. That closed off any argument about whether the hazards had existed, and left them in breach from the first deadline.
Do not re-let with category 1 hazards outstanding
Re-letting the upper flat while serious hazards remained was treated as an aggravating feature by the council.
Conversions carry fire risk
An older house divided into flats without proper fire separation between units and along the escape route is a category 1 fire hazard waiting to be recorded. The fire hazards weighed heavily in the finding of high harm.
Joint owners are both liable
Each owner who is served and fails to comply commits the offence, whoever deals with the builders.
Where a surveyor fits in
A chartered building surveyor can help at each stage:
- Before enforcement. A condition survey of a rented property that follows the rating system's hazard headings identifies damp, cold, falls and fire risks before a tenant complains.
- When a notice arrives. An independent inspection tests whether the hazards and the specified works are justified, which is the evidence needed for an appeal within the time limit. It also produces a realistic programme for a request to extend time.
- During the works. A specification and inspections at key stages make sure the remedy addresses the cause, such as insulation and ventilation for condensation, and proper fire stopping between flats.
- At completion. A dated completion report with photographs is clear evidence of when each hazard was removed. That goes directly to the harm assessment if a penalty is later considered.
- Before the tribunal. Where a penalty is appealed, a surveyor's evidence on what remained outstanding, how serious it was and why delay occurred addresses exactly the question the Upper Tribunal found had not been answered.
What this means in Manchester
Greater Manchester has a large stock of pre-1919 terraces, many converted to flats or let as shared houses, and local authorities across the region use civil penalties and licensing actively. With Awaab's Law now setting fixed timescales for social landlords to deal with damp and mould, and extending to further hazards, tolerance for long-running hazards in rented homes is low in every tenure.
For private landlords the message from this decision is practical. Know the condition of the property, respond to notices within their deadlines, and keep evidence of what was done and when.
How Manchester Surveyors can help
We carry out condition and hazard surveys of rented houses and flats across Manchester, Salford, Stockport and Trafford, prepare specifications for remedial works, and provide independent reports for improvement notice and civil penalty appeals.
Frequently asked questions
What did the Upper Tribunal decide in Sheffield City Council v El-Saadawy?
On 13 November 2026 it allowed the council's appeal on one ground, held that harm should have been assessed as high, and increased the penalty from £2,500 to £3,750 for each offence, a total of £7,500 for each landlord.
What is a category 1 hazard?
It is a serious hazard identified under the Housing Health and Safety Rating System, such as severe damp and mould, excess cold or a significant fire risk. A council has a duty to take enforcement action when it finds one.
How is harm assessed for a civil penalty?
In this case the Upper Tribunal said the relevant harm is that arising from the property remaining in a hazardous state after the works required by the notice should have been completed.
Can a landlord challenge an improvement notice?
Yes. There is a right of appeal to the First-tier Tribunal within a short time limit. A landlord who does not appeal cannot later dispute that the hazards existed.
This article is a general summary of a published decision for information only and is not legal advice.